Losing Ground, or Just Treading Water?

Losing Ground, or Just Treading Water?

In his 1984 book Losing Ground, Charles Murray called "latent poverty" -- the number of people who are poor, plus those who are not poor but would be without government assistance -- "the most damning statistic." To him it showed that poverty programs were not helping people escape poverty, but rather were trapping them in dependency. Here is his graph ("net poverty" takes into account some safety-net programs that the official measure does not):

And here, via Wonkblog, is a similar graph that runs through the present, depicting the "anchored supplemental poverty measure" with and without the safety net:

This chart paints a different picture of the 1970s than Murray's did -- it doesn't show us "losing ground." But as Wonkblog explains, it doesn't show us gaining any, either, all the way up to the present. Since the beginning of the welfare state, self-sufficiency has stagnated.

Robert VerBruggen is editor of RealClearPolicy. Twitter: @RAVerBruggen

Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles